Regulatory & Disciplinary
Notifications to the FCA
Regulated firms and approved persons are under an obligation to notify the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), or where relevant the Prudential Regulation Authority, about certain events. The consequences of not doing so can be serious.
Obligations on regulated firms
Pursuant to Principle 11 of the FCA’s Principles for Businesses, regulated firms are required to disclose to the FCA appropriately anything relating to the firm of which the FCA would reasonably expect notice.
Principle 11 applies to both regulated and unregulated activities that a regulated firm conducts and also the activities of other members of a group that the regulated firm is a member of as well as any appointed representatives.
Notifications should be made in a specified form, a SUP 15 form, to which all relevant documents should be attached.
Guidance on compliance with Principle 11
Principle 11 is drafted broadly. Chapter 15 of the FCA’s Supervision manual sets out some examples of the type of event or change in condition which a regulated firm should consider notifying in accordance with Principle 11. These examples include:
- any matter which could have a significant adverse impact on the firm’s reputation;
- an application to dissolve the firm or to strike it off the Register of Companies; and
- the firm becoming aware that an employee may have committed a fraud against one of its customers.
Whilst the FCA has provided some examples of the types of circumstances in which a SUP 15 notification is likely to arise, it has avoided providing comprehensive advice to firms. Therefore, regulated firms will need to exercise careful and considered judgement when determining whether or not to make a SUP 15 notification to the FCA. This may sometimes involve finely balanced decisions. External legal advice can assist firms in navigating this decision making.
Obligations on approved persons
Pursuant to Statement of Principle 4 of the FCA’s Statements of Principle, an approved person is required to disclose to the FCA appropriately any information of which the FCA would reasonably expect notice.
Guidance on compliance with Statement of Principle 4
Just like Principle 11, Statement of Principle 4 is drafted broadly and the FCA has not provided comprehensive advice about what will and what will not be considered a breach of it.
However, in its Handbook, the FCA does provide examples of conduct that it considers do not comply with Statement of Principle 4. This includes failing without good reason to attend an interview or answer questions put by the FCA, despite a request or demand having been made.
Approved persons will need to make a careful and considered assessment when deciding whether or not to make a notification to the FCA. Factors that approved persons may wish to consider include the nature of the issue, whether the issue arises from the business area that they are responsible for, what the firm’s internal process is for escalating such an issue and whether the issue is likely to be of material significance to the FCA. External legal advice can be of valuable assistance to approved persons when making this decision.
Consequences of not notifying the FCA
If a regulated firm or an approved person does not notify the FCA of something that the FCA considers that it would reasonably have expected notice of, the FCA may decide to take supervisory and/or enforcement action.
Supervisory action can include requiring a regulated firm to commission an independent review by a skilled person and varying or imposing requirements on the firm’s permission. Enforcement action can include significant financial penalties being imposed on regulated firms and approved persons as well as prohibitions for approved persons.
Key takeaways
Staff should be routinely trained on what could constitute a notifiable issue and firms should have a clear mechanism for escalating internally and notifying to the FCA any such issue.
Timely and complete document management is essential to ensure there is a clear record of a decision on whether to disclose a matter to the FCA and its rationale. If there are any telephone or in-person discussions or meetings about the matter, a comprehensive note or minute should be made that is as contemporaneous as possible.
Compliance and Legal colleagues should be involved in the decision making.
Information provided to the FCA should be checked carefully to ensure it is thorough and accurate and any inadvertent errors or omissions should be promptly flagged to the FCA.
